Monthly Archives: July 2012

Celebrating a school choice pioneer

School choice has entered a new world. Americans are becoming increasingly vocal about the importance of empowering parents to choose their children’s schools, and states across the nation, including Ohio, are adopting broad-based school choice initiatives.

The “Christopher Columbus” of school choice in this country is Nobel-prize winning economist Milton Friedman, who pioneered this movement more than 50 years ago.

In 1955, Friedman introduced school choice as a way to improve the quality of American education. His idea was simple: give parents access to their children’s public education funding rather than require they attend the public schools nearest to their homes.

“Governments could require a minimum level of education which they could finance by giving parents vouchers redeemable for a specified maximum sum per child per year if spent on ‘approved’ educational services,” Friedman wrote in 1955. “Parents would then be free to spend this sum and any additional sum on purchasing educational services from an ‘approved’ institution of their own choice.”

At first, Friedman’s suggestions lived mostly as an academic exercise with little in the way of new programs. And without the reforms he suggested, the cost of public education doubled while its academic performance stayed the same. As Friedman noted, that shouldn’t come as a surprise because that’s exactly what monopolies do. They offer a product of similar, if not worse, value at a higher price than normally would be allowed if they had to compete in the free market.

But those days are over. Parents are fed up, wondering why their kids are underperforming or unmotivated in K-12 schools and unprepared for their college courses and future careers. They want the life-changing opportunity to choose the school that will best prepare their child for lifelong success. Parents are demanding that their children receive a high quality education that best meets their learning needs.

Because of that sentiment, last year a historic number of choice programs were enacted across the country. Substantiating that momentum, The Wall Street Journal called 2011 “The Year of School Choice” and school choice programs have continued to expand in 2012.

Today, 18 states and the District of Columbia provide some type of private school choice for their residents. Already in 2012, Virginia has joined the school choice “family;” New Hampshire’s legislature has passed a school choice measure; Florida and Arizona expanded their programs; and Louisiana dramatically increased the scope of its school voucher program.

In Ohio, we recently saw the creation of the Jon Peterson Special Needs Scholarship Program, a scholarship that allows any student with special needs to attend the public or private school of their choice. Along with Ohio’s three other school voucher programs – the EdChoice Scholarship Program, the Cleveland Scholarship and Tutoring Program, and the Ohio Autism Scholarship Program – and a growing number of outstanding public school options, Ohio families now enjoy more opportunities than ever to find a great school that is a great fit for their children.

This month would have been Milton Friedman’s 100th birthday. Though it took America more than 50 years to reach today’s environment in which parent empowerment in education is celebrated and not ridiculed, the battle was worth it.

As the school choice movement gathers momentum, it is changing lives one by one as it allows students to reach their true potential and empowers parents with options.

Statewide Study of Student Mobility

School Choice Ohio is excited to sponsor, along with the Thomas B. Fordham Institute and many others, a Statewide Study of Student Mobility conducted by Community Research Partners. They did a similar study for Columbus City Schools, but this will be the first statewide study in Ohio.

The study will use data from the Ohio Department of Education to look at student mobility trends across the state and how students are moving between schools, including charter and magnet schools. It is among the first of its kind and scale in the U.S. and is expected to be complete in the fall.

5 reasons to incorporate more career education into high school curricula

Our director of community programs, Sarah Pechan, was on vacation in Arizona this summer and found the whole state buzzing about the issue of school choice. She shares some of the perspective of parents she met while rafting through the Grand Canyon’s Colorado River.

As I mentioned in my post earlier this week, when the conversations on the river or hikes turned to school choice and education policy, a hot topic was incorporating more career education and real world work into high school curricula. Lots of great reasons came up and people were happy to hear that this is already a hot topic in education policy through the work of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and others.

Reason to incorporate more career education #1: To put it bluntly, high school is pretty lame.
Education observers have long noted that students often drop out of high school not because of family issues or because they can’t read. They drop out because they see school as irrelevant to their lives and have become completely disengaged. One of our river guides skipped most of his classes in high school but is an extremely talented young man and now studies physics in college.

Reason to incorporate more career education #2: Hands on jobs often pay pretty darn well.
Our rafting trip leader, a geologist, was passionate about career education: “We need to decrease the stigma against career education. Graduates of career programs often make more money than if they had gone to college, usually in jobs that can’t be outsourced. People who work with their hands often have higher job satisfaction too.”

Reason to incorporate more career education #3: We all could stand to know more about how the world around us works.
Knowing philosophy and literature is really important. But so is knowing how small engines and waste water and personal finance work. I think I would feel like a more well-rounded human being if I had learned more about these things.

Reason to incorporate more career education #4: Our economy could boom from a generation of entrepreneurs and technology-competent workers.
This recent article calls Ohio employers “frustrated” that they can’t find more qualified employees. Likewise, schools like ePrep are preparing entrepreneurs to create small businesses that fuel our economy.

Reason to incorporate more career education #5: Nothing stinks more than spending 4 years and $40,000 to get a degree that you find out your first year on the job you really hate.
The earlier students start exploring career options, the earlier they can start heading in the right direction for them. This means they spend less time in college or post-secondary education wandering from major to major trying to find a good fit.

The lone dissenting voice came from a vascular surgeon in Bel Air (home of the Fresh Prince) who said he didn’t support skills-based education until the graduate education level. He said K-12 should be for students to learn how to study, undergrad should teach students how to think, and graduate school should teach students how to “do” something.

But as someone who personally emerged from high school recognizing that my primary competency was test taking, which is not exactly a helpful skill in the real world, I’ve got to believe that we can do better.

The Cristo Rey network of schools is a great example: they incorporate corporate internships into their college-prep curriculum. Students are engaged in the outside world and learning things they can bring back to the classroom. This mutually reinforcing study-practice rhythm of education makes sense.

What if Ohio ran with this model and expanded it into a broader apprentice system beyond the corporate world? This is what fellow hiker Debby shared has worked brilliantly for her son in Switzerland.

“In Switzerland, we have a strong apprenticeship system and career education system that allows students to explore concrete areas that interest them. As parents we save money on college expenses when our students have already had a chance to narrow down their fields of interest.”

Ohio has some truly outstanding career options through the College TechPrep program, but they require students to sign up for a separate program outside of their regular high school curricula. What if we were to offer biotechnology, graphic design, entertainment, and information technology courses alongside the geometry, AP English, and physics courses to allow all Ohio high schoolers access to a more dynamic high school experience?

- Sarah

Make your voice heard as the legislature considers reforming school funding in Ohio

This summer, the House of Representatives has been busy considering options for reforming the way the state funds public education in Ohio.

Since May, the Ohio House Finance Committee and the Primary/Secondary Education Subcommittee have heard testimony from experts on the current method of funding schools, as well as proposals on ways to improve the system. School Choice Ohio testified to before the committee on June 28.

In order to encourage more participation in the process from the public, the Committee, led by committee chairman Representative Ron Amstutz (R- Wooster), will be holding a series of hearings across the state beginning Monday, July 23. The schedule for the hearings is below:

July 23, 2012
6:00 – 8:00 P.M.
Warren County Educational Service Center
1879 Deerfield Road, Lebanon, Ohio 45036
Topics to be addressed: Technology and Regional/Shared Services
Click here for directions

August 14, 2012
6:00 – 8:00 P.M.
Lima High School
1 Spartan Way, Lima, Ohio 45801
Topics to be addressed: Human Capital Management, Productivity and Performance-Based Funding
Click here for directions

August 22, 2012
6:00 – 8:00 P.M.
Sen. Oliver R. Ocasek Government Building
161 S. High Street
Akron, OH, 44308
Topics to be addressed: Categorical Funding and Weighted Student Funding
Click here for directions

These hearings are a great opportunity for anyone who is interested in expanded school choice to have a chance to share your thoughts with the members of the committee without having to travel all the way to Columbus. While the hearings have specific topics of discussion listed, members of the public will be permitted to speak about any issue concerning school funding.

If you are interested in participating in one of these hearings, please contact Jason Warner, SCO’s legislative director, at 614-223-1555 or jwarner@scohio.org. He can assist in the process of preparing testimony and submitting it to the committee for consideration.

SCO’s Sarah Pechan talks school choice with Arizona parents

Our director of community programs, Sarah Pechan, was on vacation in Arizona this summer and found the whole state buzzing about the issue of school choice. She shares some of the perspective of parents she met while rafting through the Grand Canyon’s Colorado River.

As I was getting to know my fellow rafters on the Colorado River and fellow hikers in the Grand Canyon, I was surprised by the number of Arizona parents who shared their personal experiences when they heard that I work in the arena of school choice. It was pretty incredible and encouraging to hear so I wanted to share just a couple of their stories with you:

  • Heidi, a former park ranger, lit up when I mentioned school choice. Her daughter Megan is in 8th grade at a charter school. This is her first year at the school and the first year in her academic career that a school has both pushed Megan to achieve more and given her the support she needs for her dyslexia. Heidi said she has been amazed at how the higher expectations at the charter school have engaged her daughter, who was really starting to hate school. Now Megan is excited about school and pushing herself to rise to the higher standards.

But I couldn’t blame her when she said that she and her husband are pulling Megan out of this school next year because the hours and hours of nightly homework don’t leave time for Megan to pursue her interests in theater.

  • Jake, a river guide, said he saw a night and day difference in his son after he started attending a Montessori-style charter school this year. His 5th-grader went from having nothing to say about school for the first 5 years of his education to now being really excited to share what he has learned every day. Jake is thrilled and said the Montessori approach was just the right one for his son.

All of the work we do at a policy level is to simply make a way for these types of stories. To borrow a river analogy, advocates and legislators are working upstream to make sure the resources, laws, and flexibility are available to create better opportunities for students. The real magic is at the student level: education entrepreneurs working hard to grow quality, creative schools, parents taking the initiative to explore their options and find the best fit for their child, and students making the most of the privilege of an education.

These stories from across the country echo stories that we hear right here in Ohio all the time. They are such beautiful stories of all of us winning because of the options that are available to families.

Another education/school choice issue that came up a lot was skill-based, hands-on education. I’ll talk more about that later in the week. Stay tuned!

- Sarah

Ohio School Choice and Education News

July 5 – July 12, 2012

Ohio

Principals will start seeing the same scrutiny as teachers when new evaluation system goes statewide next fall
The Plain Dealer
July 6, 2012
Ohio will require districts to have an evaluation system for principals in place by the 2013-14 school year. The goal of the evaluation system is to help principals perform better, which will also improve schools. The Plain Dealer reports that the Cleveland school district plans to adjust pay for principals partly based on their evaluations.

Reading guarantee for Ohio 3rd-graders starts with September screenings
The Plain Dealer
July 8, 2012
Beginning this school year, Ohio school districts and charter schools must screen students in grades K-3 by September 30 to evaluate their reading levels. Within 60 days following the screening, the schools must prepare a plan to help students who need it as part of the state’s new third-grade reading guarantee.

CPS to reluctantly sell buildings
The Cincinnati Enquirer
July 9, 2012
Cincinnati Public Schools will sell at least five closed school buildings this summer. State law requires that charter school operators have the first opportunity to buy the buildings. Emmy Partin, director of policy and research for the Thomas B. Fordham Institute tells The Enquirer that the buildings were paid for with public school dollars, so it makes sense to re-purpose them for that use.

Dover schools to launch new Internet teaching initiative
The Times-Reporter
July 9, 2012
In the 2012-13 school year, the Dover City School District will launch a new program that will allow students to access a new wireless network for educational purposes using their own technology. A high school principal for the district tells The Times-Reporter that the goal of the new program is to promote student learning and teach students to use the technology in a responsible way.

Students say school’s too easy
Dayton Daily News
July 11, 2012
The Center for American Progress recently released a study that found millions of students across the U.S. are not challenged enough in the classroom. They analyzed data from the Department of Education’s National Assessment of Educational Progress for the study.

Ohio plans tougher high-school tests
The Cincinnati Enquirer
July 8, 2012
Beginning in the 2014-15 school year, Ohio will exchange its statewide graduation test for a series of more rigorous high school exams. An Ohio Department of Education official tells The Enquirer that the new tests will measure student readiness for college or a career.

Westerville phasing out popular magnet schools
The Columbus Dispatch
July 8, 2012
Two magnet schools in Westerville, Longfellow Elementary and Central College Elementary, closed this summer due to budget cuts. Following this school year, the district says it plans on closing its remaining magnet schools and will instead hold magnet classes in schools districtwide.

National

Close to 9,000 Louisiana students apply for private school vouchers
The Times-Picayune
July 11, 2012
Nearly 9,000 students applied for the first time to Louisiana’s new school voucher program. Louisiana’s Superintendent John White also released a list of criteria that participating private schools will have to meet, which covers enrollment, finances and student attrition. He will outline the academic accountability plan in a later document.

Nearly 400 Cleveland high school students apply for Cleveland school voucher

For the first time in the program’s history, Cleveland high school students were eligible to apply this year for the Cleveland Scholarship and Tutoring Program. The application period closed on May 31, and the Ohio Department of Education reports that a total of 398 high school students applied.

High school eligibility for the Cleveland scholarship program was added to the budget that Governor Kasich signed on June 30, 2011. Prior to that, only students in grades K-8 were eligible to apply.

Without this change in eligibility, these 398 students would have had to struggle to pay for private high school or simply leave. Now, their families can focus on saving money for college instead of worrying about paying private high school tuition.

Some families eligible for transportation payment

Parents – did you know that if your child is eligible for busing but doesn’t receive it, you could be eligible to receive a payment from the state? Here is how it works:

  • A student is eligible to receive school bus transportation if they live farther than two miles from the school and closer than 30 minutes. However, some districts deny students busing saying they are “impractical to transport.”
  • Parents of those children are eligible for a $225.22 payment from the district for making sure that their children arrive at school. Eligible families can apply for this payment through their home school district.
  • In winter or spring of the following year, parents who applied for the payment will receive a check in the mail from the district. These payments can be pro-rated for a partial year if needed.

The payment amount is not even close to the cost of having to transport a child to and from school for a year, and the family has to wait a long time for the payment, so we hope the Ohio Department of Education will improve this option for Ohio families. But, in the meantime, it is a resource that is available for those eligible families that already transport their own children.

Ohio School Choice and Education News

June 28 – July 6, 2012

Ohio

Schools air funding beefs during Ohio House hearings
The Columbus Dispatch
June 29, 2012
In a hearing last week before an Ohio House subcommittee, School Choice Ohio gave testimony in support of student-centered funding. SCO’s Jason Warner encouraged those at the hearing to imagine the possibilities that would come from giving parents options about where to spend the funding allocated for their children.  The subcommittee is preparing for an overhaul of Ohio’s school-funding formula.

Ohio Gov. John Kasich signs Cleveland schools plan into law (video)
The Plain Dealer
July 2, 2012
On Monday, Governor Kasich signed The Cleveland Plan for Transforming Schools into law. All four bill sponsors joined Governor Kasich, Cleveland Mayor Frank Jackson, Cleveland Schools CEO Eric Gordon, Ohio House Speaker Bill Batchelder, school board Chairperson Denise Link, and Cleveland Teachers Union official Tracy Radich for the signing. Governor Kasich said, “Cleveland is now leading the way in school reform.”

Ohio gets more funds for blind
Springfield News-Sun
July 5, 2012
Ohio saw an increase it its share of federal funding that helps districts pay for materials for vision-impaired students from $429,039 in 2007 to $561,475 in 2011. The Ohio Department of Education tells The News-Sun that it is working to increase awareness and efforts to count eligible students in Ohio. The executive director of the Ohio Coalition for the Education of Children with Disabilities stresses that the materials are one step, but there is still more to do.

GED offers different kind of graduation
The Cincinnati Enquirer
July 3, 2012
In this article, The Enquirer shares the stories of four people who took an alternate route to get their General Education Development diploma (GED) after dropping out of school because of boredom, parenthood, or bullying. Across the U.S., approximately 460,000 people will earn their GED this year.

National

Scholarships, distressed school districts are focus of bills
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
July 5, 2012
Pennsylvania recently expanded its Educational Improvement Tax Credit program by increasing its funds from $75 million to $100 million and creating a $50 million Opportunity Scholarship Program. Low-income students who attend the state’s lowest-performing schools in the state will be eligible for the new scholarship program.

SCO awards Courage Awards in memory of Fannie Lewis

In 1980, Fannie M. Lewis was elected to the Cleveland City Council. Lewis was a strong advocate of school vouchers. The Plain Dealer called the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in the Zelman v. Simmons-Harris case one of her biggest victories.

“It’s like a burning house. You know, what do you do, let the house burn down and kill everybody or go in there and save who you can? And that’s what the voucher’s about. If I decide that I want to take a voucher and go shop for my child then I ought to be able to do that…Why do you want to limit me to where I can go and buy my education from?”
-Fannie M. Lewis  (Frontline, “The Battle over School Choice” Air date 5/23/00)

For having the courage to stand up for Cleveland’s children, Fannie M. Lewis will forever be remembered as an inspiration and a champion for school choice. During our recent celebration in Cleveland, we honored Senator Nina Turner, Representative Bill Patmon, and Friends of Breakthrough Schools President John Zitzner with School Choice Ohio Courage Awards in memory of Fannie Lewis, and in honor of their unwavering commitment to securing a quality education for Cleveland students. See their acceptance speeches below.